Volume III · Managed Decline
The Broken Window State
Research preview · manuscript under review
Studies drug policy, courts, probation, and treatment-related incentives as an institutional framework whose proposed mechanisms require empirical evaluation.
Research programme: Siddhartha Harsh Wardhan · Preview updated
The research question
How should courts, probation and treatment systems be evaluated by their incentives and outcomes?
How it connects to Volume III
Brings institutional responses to hardship into the same frame as prevention, recovery and public capacity.
Evidence and limits
Separate legal authority, program financing and measured outcomes. Proposed institutional incentives require evidence; this preview does not attribute misconduct or offer treatment advice.
Do supervision records tell us whether people recover?
Imagine a program reports 120 check-ins and the amount it collected in supervision fees. The check-ins count activity. The fees describe a financial burden or a revenue stream, depending on whose records you are reading. Neither tells you how many people had stable housing or remained connected to care after supervision ended.
Start with everyone who entered the program, including people who left early. Use the same follow-up rule for each person, such as six months after leaving. Define housing stability and continuity of care before collecting the data, and report how many people could not be reached. To study whether the program made a difference, compare with a similar group and account for differences in eligibility, local services and starting circumstances.
A 2011 evaluation funded by the National Institute of Justice found that participants in the adult drug courts it studied reported less drug use and offending than a comparison group. Those outcomes matter alongside housing and access to care. SAMHSA describes recovery more broadly, including health, a stable home, meaningful activity and supportive relationships. The fictional example makes no claim about the effect of fees on any of these outcomes.
Continue the inquiry
- Homelessness Manufacture — Research preview
- From Pockets to Portfolios — Research preview